Your startup’s hiring advantage is finding talented people before their résumés make them obvious to everyone else. Dalton Caldwell and Michael Seibel discuss how to recognize that talent, give people room to grow, and act when a hire is not working out.
Start with the job you actually need done. Someone who can solve today’s problems may grow into tomorrow’s responsibilities. Requiring every early employee to arrive with experience running a large team rules out people who could become great at it—just as you expect to grow as a founder.
Think about the candidate’s choice, too. Why would they join your startup instead of an established company? Responsibility, difficult problems, and the chance to prove themselves can matter more to the right person than a familiar employer. A short résumé is not evidence of low ability. Evaluate what someone can do, including what you have seen them build or contribute on projects together.
The same reasoning applies to executives. Before hiring an expensive stranger with an impressive title, consider the strongest people already on your team. You know their work. Promoting them also shows everyone else that they can build a career at your company rather than leave to get more responsibility.
Dalton and Michael also question whether AI will change how many people a successful company needs. Hiring managers for the large organization you imagine building may be premature. Headcount is not the same as impact.
Taking chances on people does not mean ignoring a hire who is struggling. Avoiding an honest conversation can hurt both that person and their colleagues. Compassion means treating people well, including offering severance and help finding a better fit—not keeping them in a role that is making everyone miserable.
Their practical check: after 90 days, ask how you would feel if the person resigned. Relief is a signal worth confronting. Build a team whose potential you believe in, give them room to grow, and be honest about whether it is working.